Skip to content
Licensed providers in all 50 statesLicensed U.S. pharmaciesDiscreet 2–5 business day deliveryUnlimited messaging with your care teamFSA & HSA eligibleThird-party tested supplementsCancel anytime
Reoptive

Five testosterone myths, and what the evidence says

From heart risk to fertility, a clear look at what testosterone therapy can and cannot do.

Written by
James WhitfieldPA-C
Medically reviewed by
Dr. Marcus BellMD, Endocrinology
Published
6 min read
A man lifting a kettlebell in a bright, minimal home gym

Testosterone attracts strong opinions. Some see it as a fountain of youth; others consider it dangerous for anyone. The evidence sits in between, and the answer depends heavily on who is being treated and why.

Myth 1: Low energy at 40 means low testosterone

Fatigue, low libido and low mood are common, and they have many possible causes, including poor sleep, sleep apnea, depression, thyroid conditions, medications, excess weight and alcohol. Testosterone deficiency, or hypogonadism, is diagnosed only when consistent symptoms are paired with consistently low levels. The Endocrine Society recommends confirming a low result with a repeat early-morning fasting test, because levels peak in the morning and vary from day to day.

Myth 2: Your number alone decides whether you need treatment

Reference ranges are a guide, not a verdict. Some men with levels near the lower end feel well, while others with similar numbers have clear symptoms. A good evaluation looks at the whole picture: symptoms, total and sometimes free testosterone, LH and FSH to understand the cause, and markers such as hematocrit and PSA where appropriate.

Myth 3: Testosterone therapy causes heart attacks

This concern grew from mixed observational studies in the 2010s. In 2023 the TRAVERSE trial, which randomized more than 5,000 men with hypogonadism and existing or high risk of cardiovascular disease, found that testosterone therapy was noninferior to placebo for major cardiovascular events over a mean follow-up of nearly three years.

The same trial saw higher rates of atrial fibrillation, acute kidney injury and pulmonary embolism in the testosterone group. The results are reassuring for appropriately selected men, and they are also a reminder of why monitoring matters.

Myth 4: Testosterone therapy causes prostate cancer

Current evidence does not show that testosterone therapy causes prostate cancer in men with hypogonadism. Guidelines still recommend assessing prostate cancer risk before starting and monitoring PSA during treatment, because testosterone can stimulate existing prostate tissue. Men with known prostate or breast cancer are generally not candidates.

Myth 5: Testosterone has no effect on fertility

This one matters, and many men never hear it. Taking testosterone signals the brain to reduce LH and FSH, the hormones that drive sperm production. As a result, testosterone therapy can lower sperm counts substantially, sometimes to zero.

If you hope to have children in the near future, tell your provider before starting. Medications that encourage your body's own production, such as enclomiphene or hCG, may be worth discussing. Some of these are used off-label or are compounded, and compounded medications are not FDA-approved.

What treatment involves

If you and a licensed provider decide that testosterone therapy is appropriate, expect a baseline evaluation and regular follow-up. Monitoring typically includes testosterone levels, hematocrit (testosterone can raise red blood cell counts), PSA when indicated and a review of your symptoms. The aim is to bring levels into a mid-normal range and improve how you feel, not to push numbers as high as possible.

Testosterone comes in several forms, including weekly or twice-weekly injections, daily gels and longer-acting options. Each has trade-offs in convenience, cost and how steady levels stay between doses. Gels can transfer to partners or children through skin contact, so washing hands and covering the application site matters. Your provider can help you weigh which form fits your routine and health history.

The bottom line

Testosterone therapy can meaningfully help men with confirmed deficiency. It is not a shortcut to fitness, and it is not right for everyone. A careful diagnosis, an honest conversation about fertility and risk, and ongoing monitoring make the difference.

Selected sources

  1. Bhasin S, et al. Testosterone therapy in men with hypogonadism: an Endocrine Society clinical practice guideline. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2018;103:1715-1744.
  2. Lincoff AM, et al. Cardiovascular safety of testosterone-replacement therapy (TRAVERSE). N Engl J Med. 2023;389:107-117.
  3. Mulhall JP, et al. Evaluation and management of testosterone deficiency: AUA guideline. J Urol. 2018;200:423-432.

This article is for general education and is not medical advice. It does not replace a conversation with a licensed provider who knows your health history. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call 911.

Men’s Health at Reoptive

Care related to this article

Prescription programs are available only if a licensed provider determines treatment is appropriate.

Omega Pure by Reoptive
LG-03
4.8(1,720 reviews)

Omega Pure

High-potency omega-3 for heart and brain.

$34$42

Subscribe & save 19%

Compounded medications are prepared by licensed U.S. pharmacies and are not FDA-approved. Individual results vary.

Reoptive MD

Turn reading into a plan.

A short online assessment, reviewed by a licensed provider. If treatment is appropriate, your plan ships discreetly. If it is not, we will tell you why.